Home | Hegemony | Archives | Blogroll | Resume | Links | RSS Feed    

curtesy bobharris.com

Flagrancy

to Reason

 

break out | main

attacking iran is dumb
casmii
clark
folly
the usual suspects
unusual suspects

under our bombs, over the sea
the human cost
moratorium time
juan cole
as'ad abuKhalil
missing links
reidar visser
salam pax, raed, & baghdad burning
dahr jamail
rahul mahajan
today in iraq
the occupation project

roohullah rahimi

mukhtar ainashe

lebanon updates

"labels are not more than open boxes"

one big wobblosphere
IWW News
Retail Worker
eric lee
eugene plawiuk
f n brill
j m branum
k marx the spot
kevin carson
mark dilley
rob findlay
thomas l knapp

ilk
anarchoblogs
art of the possible
andrew o baoill
andrew levin
arthur silber
chris dillow
cosma shalizi
course correction
daniel davies
dave pollard
dennis perrin
doug henwood
dru oja jay - dominion
hugo zoom
jeff vail
john caruso
jonathan schwarz
karmalised
kevin harris
libertarian labyrinth
mark ames
max sawicky [defunkt :(]
michael perelman
mitchell freedman
naomi klein
nell lancaster
norman solomon
the open mind
our tomorrow
press action
richard stallman
sam smith
stop me before i vote again
ufo breakfast
sedition
seth edenbaum
stay free!
upaya
vermont commons
who is ioz
znet blogs

fire your boss
thwarted efforts

econ
dean baker
nouriel roubini
calculated risk
cepr blog
econospeak
general glut
globalize this!
robert waldmann
walden bello

strikes and drives
glabour
jordan barab
labor blog
rafael gely [law]
NEWMAN!!
thomas palley
work less
working family party
--
Borders Union
Congress Hotel Strike
Houston Janitors
Starbucks Union
TC Metro

Scottish Socialist SF Vanguard
ken macleod

'i am no marxist!'
bionic octopus
lenin's tomb
stan goff

progressives
cursor
american amnesia
bitch, phd
cernig
crooked timber
david corn
doug ireland
fables of the reconstruction
fester
jordan klein
ken silverstein
prometheus 6
rootless cosmopolitan
robert dreyfuss
sadly, no!
scott horton
seeing the forest
steve perry

religious 'left'
gutless pacifist
abbas kadhim [shia]
helena cobban
martin kelly [quaker]
ray mcgovern
rev. allen h. brill
rootsblog [hoodoo]
shiapundit
skip schiel
veiled4allah

liberal
christopher allbritton
order of the shrill
pacific views
paul krugman
sideshow
spencer ackerman
suburban guerrilla
war and piece
unfogged

unfair, unbalanced
argmax
arms control wonk
bruce schneier
capital spectator
craig murray
defending ethics
drugwar rant
eric umansky
gary brecher
grok law
housing crash
housing crash...
lawrence lessig
mark crispin miller
make
memory hole
murketing
robert fisk
sanders research associates
scott atran
steve aftergood
war is boring

heathens & heretics
gristmill
real climate
tim lambert

satellite dish hats
rigorous intuition

long emergencies
clusterfuck nation chronicle
energy bulletin
the oil drum
r-squared energy

miscreants
alicublog
the curmudgeon
fafnir
adam felber
filthy critic, the
ironic times
jay pinkerton
jon swift
neal pollack
opinions you should have
rude pundit
the lowest deep

libertarian
antiwar blog
the agitator
balkinization
entitled to an opinion
freedom democrats
jim bovard
jim henley
john smith
julian sanchez
kerry howley
liberty & power
nebojsa malic
vaguely right
wally conger
wendy mcelroy

conservosaurus rex
charles reese
joe stromberg
justin raimondo
old man 1787 [rip]
karen kwiatkowski

conservative
arnold kling
brian carnell
daniel drezner
john cole
james joyner
kesher talk
klayman & verney
tacitus

unreasonable searches and seizures
checkpoint usa
papers, please!

homeless
claire bushey
thehomelessguy

run for the hills
counter-terror

flibbertigibbets
george monbiot
robert fisk

africa
alex de waal [harvard]
arab street [egypt]
crumbley [on egypt]
drima [sudan]
from the rock [libya]
slum tv [kenya]

americas
blogalization [brazil]
blog from bolivia
eparillon [trinidad]
justin delacour
narcosphere [drugs]
randy paul [latin america]
patrick barr [peru]

asia
amarji [syria]
central asian journal
committee to protect bloggers [iran]
fons tuinstra [china]
iranian girl [iran, retired]
ishtartalking [iraq]
lady sun [iran]
pedram [iran, emmigrant]
ali abtahi [iran]
the argus [on central asia]
sofia javed [in uzbekistan]
the south asian
steve levine
third world view [bangladesh]

eastern europe
a natural anthem [moldova]

iraq resources
IVAW
campaign for casualty assessments
Bodycount, Iraqi Civillians
Bodycount, Occupying Forces
GlobalSecurity: US Casualties
Comparative US Def. Spending
Oil For Food Facts
Watch, Bush on Film
Watch, Iraq Debt
Watch, Iraq Occupation
Watch, Iraq Revenue
Watch, US Bombing
Watch, Arms and The Man
Iraq Warcrimes Tribunal

the yellow peril
China Study Group
frog in a well
image thief...
lawyers, guns and money
those who dare...

katrina
Reconstruction Watch
ACORN
American Red Cross
American Second Harvest
Food Not Bombs
Habitat for Humanity
Hurricane Housing
Music Rising

a gumdrop house on lollipop lane!
after downing street
sign a letter
the british memos
timeline

tsunami
tsunami relief blog
doctors without borders
global fund

ecology
ask blogs
blogpulse
blogstreet
blogshares [*]
feedster
google blogsearch
technorati [*]
ttlb ecosystem
weblogs.com
who links me



Current or Currently Old Issues:


    george w. bonaparte..., 2007-08-23 16:58:53 | Main | Family Security Matters more than the Republic..., 2007-08-23 20:19:29

    if only we had stayed the course in cambodia:

    People keep talking like bombing Cambodia didn't start until 1969, so I'll just cross post my comment at the Atlantic to my blog while I'm at it. The factoids:

    1. The bombing actually started in 1965.
    2. 475,515 tons had been dropped on Cambodia by the time of Lon Nol's March 18th, 1970 coup.
    3. The carpet bombing campaigns intended to stop the Khmer Rouge's advance had the opposite effect. Not unlike the US Bombing Survey's finding that the allied fire bombing of Hamburg enhanced the Nazi war effort by increasing the availability of the civilian workforce for wartime production, the carpet bombing of Cambodia escalated recruitment into the Khmer Rouge. The reds were dug into bomb shelters, largely unaffected by the bombing. Using the deposed Prince Sihanouk as a nationalist front they would tell terrified Khmers that only a revolution against Lon Nol - who had granted Nixon the honor of levelling his country after taking power - could end the campaign. An example, from the PBS documentary The American Experience, on the Cambodian experience:
      NARRATOR: In less than three years, the Khmer Rouge forces had grown from 3,000 to 60,000. The Khmer Rouge were no longer completely dependent on their Vietnamese Communist allies.

      CHHIT DO (Khmer Rouge organizer): The ordinary people were terrified by the bombing and the shelling, never having experienced war, and sometimes they shit in their pants when the big bombs and shells came. Two hundred to 400 shells would fall in each attack, and some people became shell-shocked -- just like their brains were completely shattered. Even after the shelling had stopped, they couldn't hold down a meal. Their minds just froze up and they would wander around mute, not talking for three or four days. Terrified and half-crazy, they would believe anything they were told. And because there was so much shelling, they believed whatever the Khmer Rouge told them.

      TONG TENG: The fear was pervasive. Everybody was scared. But the real Reds weren't dying. They weren't being hit. The Khmer Rouge, who were doing the fighting, had dug bomb shelters. So whenever the planes came, they jumped into their holes while the people, sometimes didn't even have time to get out of their houses.

      CHHIT DO: The Khmer Rouge would say that the purpose of the bombing was to completely destroy the country, not simply just to win the war, but to annihilate the population, and that it was only because we were taking cover -- moving around to avoid the bombing -- that some of us were surviving. So they used the bombing, the bomb craters and the bomb shrapnel to educate the people politically, to make the people hate and be enraged at the Americans.

      By the time Congress ended the "secret" bombing campaign in 1973 the Khmer Rouge forces were 200,000 strong.

    4. As we know now from new data "the total payload dropped during these years [was] nearly five times greater than the generally accepted figure", a "revised total of 2,756,941 tons". In WWII the allies dropped altogether something like 2 million tons, including the nukes. In Cambodia 50% more ordnance than that left the KR stronger than when the bombing began.
    5. Complaining that we didn't drop more bombs on Cambodia is batshit insane.
    6. George W. Bush was complaining that we didn't drop more bombs on Cambodia.

    For more details see the paper from last fall based on new sortie data released by the outgoing Clinton administration, "Bombs Over Cambodia [pdf]", or scan the excerpts I posted last year.

    Congress stopped the bombing, but they didn't stop US aid to Lon Nol: the USAF operated an air bridge out of U-Tapao, Thailand [*, *] to the capital in addition to deliveries via the Mekong, transporting thousands of tons/day in supplies to the capital - which by the end of the bombing campaign in August 1973 was one of Lon Nol's last holdouts. When the Khmer Rouge came out of their foxholes they were effectively in control of most of the country.

    So: we evacuated Phnompenh in April of '75 because Lon Nol lost, despite all our continued assistance. Not leaving would have just meant leaving the American staff there, waiting around to be butchered by the victorious Khmer Rouge, assuming they wouldn't have simply escorted them out of the country as they did the other foreigners who were still in the capital.

    And just to paint this all in high comedic relief:

    KISSINGER (to the Foreign Minister of Thailand): You should also tell the Cambodians that we will be friends with them. They are murderous thugs, but we won't let that stand in our way. We are prepared to improve relations with them. Tell them the latter part, but don't tell them what I said before.

    That's from November 26th, 1975.


:: posted by buermann @ 2007-08-23 19:25:19 CST | link





    go ahead, express that vague notion
    Name:
    Email:
    Homepage:
    Comment

    your turing test:


journals, notes,
and
other curmudgeonry

Enforcing
American
Hegemony
- A Timeline -

Corporate
Bastardizations
of Culture

Government
Bastardizations
of Citizenship

Bastardized Elections

Where's the Beef?
A Very Khmer-Chomsky
"Planet Dershowitz"

Oil for Nothing:
US Holds On Humanitarian Supplies
Iraq: 1997-2001


the good book
and other cultural
artifacts


The Autobiography
of
Mother Jones

books I want

other books I want

sounds I'm listening to



Contact Info:
buermann[at]
flagrancy[dot]net

Home and Away

red cards,
my wicked past,
and other causes for suspicion

-IWW-
Chicago Branch
IU 660 and IU 560.

The American Civil Liberties Union

-WNUR-
radio libre

Union Label


random shit i've read



"Any man who is not a radical at 20 has no heart. A man who is not a cynic at 50 has no mind."
eXTReMe Tracker